Corfu channel united kingdom of great britain and northern ireland v albania merits judgment of 9 april 1949, icj reports 1949, p. International islamic university islamabad huzaifa shaukat 5070fslllbf17 section b assignment. List of international court of justice cases wikipedia. The united kingdom went ahead on november 12th and th of 1946 to sweep the corfu channel for mines, including in albanian territorial waters. Corfu channel united kingdom of great britain and northern. The corfu channel case judgment on the preliminary objection by harding f. May 26, 1948 submission of the case before the icj. In november 1946 the british royal navy swept for mines in the corfu channel in albanian waters without albanian consent. The information has been carefully selected and compiled from unhcrs global network of field. The court found that these 22 mines were of the same type german gy mines as those in the october 1946 explosions. Judgments corfu channel united kingdom of great britain. Judgment on the preliminary objection 1949 1 stanlrev 64 6657 jm jones, corfu channel case. In april, 1946, the british severed diplomatic relations with albania owing to the unfriendly and uncooperative.
Summaries of judgments, advisory opinions and orders of. The questions of supplemental jurisdiction for international environmental claims ireland vs. Albania cases next overview of the case institution of proceedings preliminary objections written proceedings oral proceedings other documents. Alducran and runbetis tapagium are like products 17 1. Kingdom that the laying of mines in the north corfu channel was effected with the connivance of albania. Many of the issues dealt with by the court in 1949 remain central questions of international law, including due diligence. The corfu channel incident scholarworks at university of montana.
Corfu channel case merits judgment of 9 april 1949 the corfu channel case united kingdom of great britain and northern irelandalbania arose from incidents that occurred on october 22nd 1946, in the corfu strait. Chapter 11 customary law, human rights and climate change. Corfu channel case merits judgment of 9 april 1949 the. In its judgment of 9 april 1949, the court avoided a. Jurisdiction 1949 35 transactions of the grotius society 91111 q wright, the corfu channel case 1949 43 ajil 491494 ww. The ships were ordered to return fires if they were attacked. International audiencein 1949 the international court of justice icj handed down its first judgment in the corfu channel case. Conditions of admission of a state to membership in the united nations.
The judgment on the merits of 1949 held albania responsible for the mine explosions of. Nov 19, 2020 on october 22, 1946, three british ships crossed the corfu channel, with the express instruction to test albanias reaction to their alleged right of innocent passage. Issues of shared responsibility before the international court of. Oct 09, 2020 0000002272 00000 n the term res judicata means a matter that has been adjudicated by a competent court and therefore may not be pursued further by the same parties. Forum prorogatum in the corfu channel case and in subsequent. Corfu channel united kingdom of great britain and northern ireland v. The judgment thon preliminary objections of 25 march 1948 constitutes a milestone in the institution of forum prorogatum in the proceedings before the icj i. However, the icj in corfu channel distinguished circumstantial evidence from direct proof and stated that indirect evidence could be drawn from inferences of fact. At the first major multilateral meeting to address international.
In support of their contention the british alleged in their reply. International court of justice icj published on by oxford university press. Chapter 118 international court of justice, judgment, corfu. Bennett, arthur alexander, the corfu channel incident 1953. Corfu channel case oxford public international law. The court does not explicitly define circumstantial evidence in its judgments. The term disappeared from his subsequent judgments, to be replaced by juridical.
The court found that these 22 mines were of the same type german gy. Judgment of 15 december 1949 assessment of the amount of compensation due from the peoples republic of albania to the united kingdom of great britain and northern ireland including the text of the declaration of the judge krylov. Alducra violated the provisions of article viii2 of arta 17 1. Trail smelter and corfu channel provide clear precedents for the development of international environmental law.
By a judgment delivered on april 9th, 1949, in the corfu channel case merits, the court declared the peoples republic of albania responsible under. Tsagourias due diligence institute for security policy and law. The corfu channel case united kingdom of great britain and northern ireland. The corfu channel case preliminary objection 1948 42 ajil 690703 hf bancroft and e stein, the corfu channel case. The corfu channel has had a lasting influence on the practice of international law, especially the law of the sea. May 15, 1946 an albanian battery fired in the direction of two 2 british cruisers that were navigating through the corfu channel. The contribution of the international court of justice to.
Bancroft and eric steint in its first decision since its establishment in i945, the international court of justice rendered a judgment rejecting albanias jurisdictional objection in the dispute arising out of the corfu channel. However, the legal framework established by the corfu channel decision was modified 1corfu channel united. Immediately after the delivery of the judgment, the court was notified by the. Refworld is the leading source of information necessary for taking quality decisions on refugee status. The corfu channel case, united kingdom of great britain and. Written submissions on behalf of the respondent iii 1. The judgment on the merits of 1949 held albania responsible for the. Although, the ship did not suffer any damages, the british govt protested, that it can make innocent passage through straits without the need to make any announcement or await permission. On the same day, the application was transmitted by the registrar to the secretarygeneral of the united nations for communication in accordance with article 40, paragraph 3, of the statute. The icj gave three judgments, the first of which rejected albanias preliminary objections, the second held.
The courts stance on the use of force was significant in subsequent judgments, such as nicaragua v. This dispute gave rise to three judgments by the court. These statements and submissions develop the points indicated in the application as constituting the claim of the united kingdom. The corfu channel case united kingdom of great britain and northern irelandalbania arose from incidents that occurred on october 22. The uk considered the channel to be free of mines, having swept the channel for mines in 1944 and again in 1945. The fact that the albanian p authorities did not make the presence of mines in its waters was the basis of the united kingdom d claim against them.
Corfu channel, united kingdom v albania, judgment, merits. The notion of innocence used by the court was eventually adopted in a number of important maritime contract laws. Summaries of judgments, advisory opinions and orders of the. Corfu channel case united kingdom albania 22 may 1947. Judgments of the icj and its predecessor the permanent court of international. Latest developments corfu channel united kingdom of great. Summary of and extract from corfu channel case united kingdom. It arose out of the explosions of mines by which some british warships suffered. Oct 10, 2020 the uk on october 22, 1946, entered the corfu channel.
Name applicant respondent case began case ended disposition 1. Judgment on the preliminary objection 1949 1 stanlrev 646657 jm jones, corfu channel case. The subsequent proceedings in corfu icj refused and issued judgment on compensation compromis cannot narrow their jurisdiction for a case they had already decided. Users without a subscription are not able to see the full. Mach 25, 1948 the uk and albania entered into a special agreement. The corfu channel case 18 notice of the application of the government of the united kingdom was given on may zznd, 1947, by the registrar of the court, to the albanian govemment by telegram m d by letter. A contentious case, it was the first of any type heard by the icj after its establishment in 1945.
Thediplomaticexchanges 3 8thesoleofthesecuritycouncil 8 4. This sweep resulted in 22 mines being found and cut. The corfu channel case i 10 irregularity, and the letter was found to constitute a voluntary and indis putable acceptance of the courts jurisdiction. This was in the days before observance of international law. Apr 12, 20 in 1949 the international court of justice icj handed down its first judgment in the corfu channel case. The corfu channel case was the first public international law case. Albania arose from incidents that occurred on october 22nd 1946, in the corfu. Albania the corfu channel case icj, 1949 an analysis. Bancroft and eric steint in its first decision since its establishment in i945, the international court of justice rendered a judgment rejecting albanias jurisdictional objection in the dispute arising out of the corfu channel incident. The memorial of the united kingdom, presented within the timelimit fixed by the order, contains statements and submissions with regard to the incidents which occurred on october 22nd, 1946, in the corfu channel.
Refworld contains a vast collection of reports relating to situations in countries of origin, policy documents and positions, and documents relating to international and national legal frameworks. In diffusing an early cold war dispute, the court articulated a set of legal principles which continue to shape our appreciation of the international legal order. General list number 2 assigned to some elements of corfu channel case. Corfu channel were severely damaged by mines in albanian waters. The albanian agent seemed to contend that an application could be filed under article 40 1 of the stat ute only if compulsory jurisdiction existed, and that in. Corfu channel corfu channel, united kingdom v albania, judgment, compensation, 1949 icj rep 244, icgj 201 icj 1949, 15th december 1949 gabcikovo gabcikovonagymaros project, hungary v slovakia, order, site visit, 1997 icj rep 3, icgj 65 icj 1997, 5th february 1997 lac lac lanoux arbitration spain v. The incident arose against a background of tension.
1267 204 211 190 921 1368 111 1220 62 1333 668 1227 1338 352 141 1146 167 966 1078 676 21 1453 713 682